Jump to content

Policy Report: Protecting Industrial Frontrunners in the EU ETS

EPICO has published a new Policy Report with Frontier Economics on strengthening the protection of industrial frontrunners under the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS). The report sets out a package of measures that policymakers can draw on to ensure that companies which invested early in decarbonisation are recognised and supported in the upcoming reform.

As the ETS reform moves forward, the question of how to treat first movers is becoming increasingly relevant. The proposals currently in discussion offer only limited protection for frontrunners, which could weaken the business case of companies that invested on the assumption of a steeper ETS trajectory.

Europe is home to a substantial number of such companies, and their experience and ambition are among the most effective levers for accelerating industrial decarbonisation, as they demonstrate a success story that can be replicated across more sectors. Strong support for frontrunners rewards early movers and preserves credible incentives for future investment.

To build a structured basis for this support, the report assesses four main policy options:

  • Conditionality relief provides a baseline "do no harm" safeguard, so early movers need not make additional investments to keep their free allocation.
  • Enhanced free allocation offers additional support, but its value falls with EUA prices, so it should complement rather than replace targeted financial support.
  • Temporary CCfD-type support is the most targeted tool, calibrated to a frontrunner's demonstrable residual cost gap rather than reimbursing sunk costs.
  • Lead-market measures strengthen demand for low-carbon products and can reduce the CCfD support needed for future projects.

Building on this analysis, the report puts forward five core recommendations:

  1. Set up an EU-wide definition of "frontrunners" based on emissions performance or early clean investment, applied consistently across Member States.
  2. Shield frontrunners from additional obligations as a "do no harm" safeguard, with early investments counting towards future requirements.
  3. Offer temporary, targeted financial support covering only the verified residual cost disadvantage, conditional on continued EU production.
  4. Treat extra free allowances as a complement to financial support, not a substitute, with their full value counted when calculating remaining support needs.
  5. Use competitive CCfD auctions within the Industrial Decarbonisation Bank for future projects, reducing public spending and allowing the frontrunner scheme to phase out.

Download the Policy Report here.